Which 2nd hard drive for my MBP 2011?

I am considering alternatives for a 2nd hard drive (SSD is key) for my 15" MBP 2011, i originally was selecting a 750gb 5400rpm drive yet i'm thinking of either of the adhering to 7200rpm drives.

1) Western Digital Scorpio Black WD7500BPKT

2) Seagate Momentus ST9750420AS

I will certainly be running great deals of Virtual Machines so i'm assuming the faster drive would certainly be a far better fit.

Exist any kind of worry about noise/vibration/battery drainpipe with either of these faster drives?

2019-12-02 03:06:21
Source Share
Answers: 2

I have the Seagate in my 2010 15" MBP and also I have actually had 0 troubles with it. It is dead quiet and also there is no resonance. My battery life remained virtually the very same after the upgrade, yet given that you are considering twin disk drives (I'm thinking you eliminated your optical drive) I would certainly anticipate to see a mild decrease in your battery life.

I would certainly stick to the 7200rpm drives over the 5400rpm myself.

2019-12-03 00:55:04

I ever before had concerns with seagates drives. That began in the 90s ...

My last one, a 7200rpm seagate given in my MBP 2009 ... was passing away after 6 months, shedding collections on a daily basis, making terrifying "clic" audios. My MBP was FROZING around 10 ~ 30s at each dead collection accessibility effort ... in the beginning, one-time a week ... after that numerous times a day. btw, if your mac freeze periodically like that day, examine the hard drive with a device like TechTool Pro, Disk energy will not report absolutely nothing .

On the various other hand, obtained 4 exterior Western Digital drives, no concerns in all , despite having the+5 y/o older one, which with a rather extensive usage (like running digital equipments). The craziest one is a large 1TB that drop from a table numerous times and also still functions flawlessly.

As a side note, my MBP is currently outfitted with an Intel SSD+the very same seagate version that Apple changed many thanks to service warranty. And also I do not have troubles with it until now, yet I'm backuping with Time equipment, consistently ...

Maybe I've simply been unfortunate with seagates, yet presume my pointer

Oh and also certainly, for VMs, 7200rpm is very advised (and also VMs on SSD are simply impressive)

2019-12-03 00:54:01