Should a canonical URL be internet search engine pleasant?

I'm making use of Drupal with internet search engine pleasant URLs. The means Drupal jobs is that there is 2 means to reference a node with SEF URLS activated:

1. The SEF means, eg. http://example.com/blog/the-answer-to-life
2. Via the node ID, eg. http://example.com/node/42

(The 2nd kind concerns a 301 to the first.)

The first course can be transformed promptly and also conveniently, the 2nd is dealt with (for the life time of the website or node). I'm not recommending it is an excellent suggestion for internet sites to transform their courses often, yet it is something that might take place, so it struck me that I could make use of the 2nd kind as a canonical URL, which would certainly suggest that the very same web page would certainly be constantly appropriately indexed, and also would certainly constantly preserve its Page Rank etc

Could individual aid detail the benefits and drawbacks of such a strategy?

0
2019-05-13 03:45:30
Source Share

My understanding is that words within the URL that match search terms are taken into consideration "top quality" suits.

I absolutely see great deals of suits based upon URL when I go looking for modern technology details solutions entailing Jargon.

By utilizing the node id link as opposed to a web content - based URL, I assume you'll match much less well, so partially. Yet, I have no referrals to support my understanding.

0
2019-05-17 16:37:08
Source

Everything Bevan claimed holds true.

Your best choice is to make use of 301 redirects from the old URL to the new one similar to Drupal performs with the note ID to the SEF url.

0
2019-05-17 16:32:55
Source

You can additionally do what stackoverflow does, which is a hybrid strategy:

http://example.com/questions/1234/question-name-slug


That means you've obtained a web page that has the title in the url, yet has an irreversible item of recognizing details there too (the inquiry id). In this manner the title can be transformed, and also customers getting to the old URL can get rerouted to the new one. Actually, you can place ANYTHING in the inquiry title location after the inquiry ID and also get to a legitimate web page. The web page they offer indicate the existing url (consisting of the existing web page title) as the approved duplicate, yet they do not reroute you.

This strategy appears to be VERY SEO pleasant, while still permitting write-up titles to transform. It could be tough to implement in drupal though.

0
2019-05-17 16:11:36
Source