Devices for tracking DB schema adjustments

What are the most effective approaches for monitoring and/or automating DB schema adjustments? Our group makes use of Subversion for variation control and also we've had the ability to automate several of our jobs in this manner (pressing accumulates to a hosting web server, releasing examined code to a manufacturing web server) yet we're still doing database updates by hand. I would love to locate or create a remedy that permits us to function successfully throughout web servers with various settings while remaining to make use of Subversion as a backend where code and also DB updates are intimidated to numerous web servers.

Several preferred software include auto-update manuscripts which identify DB variation and also use the essential adjustments. Is this the most effective means to do this also on a bigger range (throughout numerous tasks and also occasionally numerous settings and also languages)? If so, exists any kind of existing code around that streamlines the procedure or is it ideal simply to roll our very own remedy? Has any person applied something comparable prior to and also incorporated it right into Subversion post-commit hooks, or is this a negative suggestion?

While a remedy that sustains numerous systems would certainly be better, we most definitely require to sustain the Linux/Apache/MySQL/ PHP pile as most of our job gets on that system.

2019-05-04 04:58:40
Source Share
Answers: 8

I've made use of the following database task framework in Visual Studio for numerous tasks and also it is functioned rather well:


Change Scripts





Create Scripts




Our construct system after that updates the database from one variation to the next by implementing the manuscripts in the adhering to order:



Contents of Create Scripts folder



Each programmer sign in their adjustments for a certain bug/feature by adding their code onto completion of each file. As soon as a significant variation is full and also branched in resource control, the materials of the.sql documents in the Change Scripts folder are removed.

2019-05-21 21:51:24

We make use of a really straightforward however yet reliable remedy.

For new installs, we have a metadata.sql documents in the database which holds all the DB schema, after that in the construct procedure we utilize this documents to create the database.

For updates, we add the updates in the software program hardcoded. We maintain it hardcoded due to the fact that we do not such as addressing troubles prior to it actually IS a trouble, and also this example really did not confirm to be a trouble until now.

So in our software program we have something similar to this:

RegisterUpgrade(1, 'ALTER TABLE XX ADD XY CHAR(1) NOT NULL;');

This code will certainly examine if the database remains in variation 1 (which is saved in a table developed instantly), if it is obsoleted, after that the command is implemented.

To upgrade the metadata.sql in the database, we run this upgrades in your area and afterwards extract the complete database metadata.

The only point that takes place periodically, is to neglect devoting the metadata.sql, yet this isn't a significant trouble due to the fact that its very easy to examine on the construct procedure as well as additionally the only point that can take place is to make a new install with an obsolete database and also updated it on the first usage.

Additionally we do not sustain downgrades, yet it is deliberately, if something breaks on an upgrade, we recovered the previous variation and also deal with the upgrade prior to attempting once more.

2019-05-21 21:45:54

My group manuscripts out all database adjustments, and also devotes those manuscripts to SVN, in addition to each release of the application. This permits step-by-step adjustments of the database, without shedding any kind of information.

To go from one release to the next, you simply require to run the set of adjustment manuscripts, and also your database is up - to - day, and also you've still obtained all your information. It might not be the most convenient method, yet it most definitely works.

2019-05-10 12:03:50

Dump your schema right into a documents and also add it to resource control. After that a straightforward diff will certainly show you what transformed.

2019-05-10 05:34:47

It's kinda reduced technology, and also there could be a far better remedy around, yet you can simply store your schema in an SQL manuscript which can be gone to create the database. I assume you can execute a command to create this manuscript, yet I do not recognize the command however.

After that, devote the manuscript right into resource control in addition to the code that works with it. When you require to transform the schema in addition to the code, the manuscript can be signed in in addition to the code that calls for the altered schema. After that, diffs on the manuscript will certainly show diffs on schema adjustments.

With this manuscript, you can incorporate it with DBUnit or some sort of construct manuscript, so it appears it can harmonize your currently automated procedures.

2019-05-07 21:11:02

If you are making use of C#, look at Subsonic, a really valuable ORM device, yet is additionally creates sql manuscript to recreated your system and also \ or information. These manuscripts can after that be taken into resource control.

2019-05-07 20:57:38

In the Rails globe, there's the principle of movements, manuscripts in which transforms to the database are made in Ruby as opposed to a database-specific flavour of SQL. Your Ruby migration code winds up being exchanged the DDL details to your current database; this makes changing database systems really simple.

For every single adjustment you make to the database, you write a new migration. Movements commonly have 2 approaches : an "up" method in which the adjustments are used and also a "down" method in which the adjustments are reversed. A solitary command brings the database approximately day, and also can additionally be made use of to bring the database to a details variation of the schema. In Rails, movements are maintained in their very own directory site in the task directory site and also get explored variation control similar to any kind of various other task code.

This Oracle guide to Rails migrations covers movements fairly well.

Programmers making use of various other languages have actually considered movements and also have actually applied their very own language-specific variations. I recognize of Ruckusing , a PHP movements system that is imitated Rails' movements; it could be what you're seeking.

2019-05-07 19:10:38

I create folders called after the construct variations and also placed upgrade and also downgrade manuscripts therein. As an example, you can have the adhering to folders : 1.0.0, 1.0.1 and also 1.0.2. Every one has the manuscript that permits you to update or downgrade your database in between variations.

Need to a customer or consumer call you with a trouble with variation 1.0.1 and also you are making use of 1.0.2, bringing the database back to his variation will certainly not be a trouble.

In your database, create a table called "schema" where you place in the existing variation of the database. After that creating a program that can update or downgrade your database for you is very easy.

Similar to Joey claimed, if you remain in a Rails globe, make use of Migrations. : )

2019-05-07 17:22:02