What is one of the most classy evidence of the Pythagorean theory?

The Pythagorean Theorem is just one of one of the most preferred to confirm by mathematicians, and also there are many proofs available (consisting of one from James Garfield).

What's one of the most classy evidence?

My favored is this visual one:

According to cut-the-knot:

Loomis (pp. 49-50) states that the evidence "was designed by Maurice Laisnez, a senior high school child, in the Junior-Senior High School of South Bend, Ind., and also sent out to me, May 16, 1939, by his class educator, Wilson Thornton."

The evidence has actually been released by Rufus Isaac in Mathematics Magazine, Vol. 48 (1975), p. 198.

2019-05-04 07:06:52
Source Share
Answers: 7
2019-05-31 14:08:43

I actually similar to this one (photo extracted from cut-the-knot # 4)

in addition to

$$(a+b)^2 = 4\cdot\frac{1}{2}a b + c^2$$ $$\Leftrightarrow c^2 = a^2 + b^2$$

It is so clear and also very easy ...

Note: Just to make it clear, the side of the square is a+b

2019-05-31 12:37:49

More than breakdown evidence, I locate the evidence making use of resemblance most informing and also instinctive. See post by Terence Tao : go down a vertical from C to the hypotenuse Abdominal Muscle.

In the number, the triangulars whose are locations are significant x and also y resemble the initial triangular (which has location x+ y). So approving that locations of comparable right-angled triangulars are symmetrical to the squares of the hypotenuse, x :y :x+ y remain in proportion a 2 :b 2 :c 2 , which is Pythagoras's theory.

See additionally the connected conversation by Alexander Giventhal where he says that this evidence is extra basic than tiling or breakdown evidence, and also is also confirmed by Euclid. If you consider a 2 + b 2 =c 2 as the geometric outcome that the amount of locations of squares created with sides an and also b is the location of a square positioned on c, after that the Pythagorean theory holds true not simply for creating squares on the sides, yet any kind of comparable numbers. As an example, as Euclid himself confirms, something like the adhering to holds true (though it's still simply claiming a 2 + b 2 =c 2 ) :

2019-05-08 04:35:18

Not an evidence by itself, yet guide The Pythagorean Proposition by Loomis has possibly one of the most thorough collection of evidence of the Pythagorean theory.

2019-05-08 04:31:56

This is not actually an evidence, in the feeling that it relies on particular physical presumptions, yet it compels you to assume really tough concerning what those physical presumptions are. I discovered it from Mark Levi's The Mathematical Mechanic, although however I do not have a layout.

Take into consideration an aquarium in the form of a triangular prism, where the triangular ahead has vertices $A, B, C$ ($C$ is the appropriate angle) and also the triangular under has contrary vertices $A', B', C'$. Allow $a, b, c$ represent the sizes of the contrary sides. Run a pole via the side $A A'$ on which the aquarium is permitted to pivot, and also load it with water. By preservation of power, this system remains in mechanical stability.

On the various other hand, I assert (and also it is not tough to see) that the complete torque concerning the pole is symmetrical to $c^2 - b^2 - a^2$, each payment originating from the stress of the water in the container versus the equivalent side.

2019-05-08 03:17:41

The evidence that makes use of the reality that shearing a parallelogram alongside among its sides maintains location is my favored. Below's a computer animation from this site :

2019-05-07 22:54:19

My favored evidence of the Pythagorean Theorem is a grandfather clause of this picture-proof of the Law of Cosines :

Drop 3 perpendiculars and also allow the definition of cosine offer the sizes of the sub-divided sectors. After that, observe that like-colored rectangular shapes have the very same location (calculated in a little various means ) and also the outcome adheres to quickly.

When C is an appropriate angle, heaven rectangular shapes disappear and also we have the Pythagorean Theorem using what total up to Proof # 5 on Cut-the-Knot's Pythagorean Theorem page. (Keep in mind that, as stated on CtK, making use of cosine below does not total up to a void "trigonometric evidence". )

The image benefits obtuse C too. (Evidence left as a workout for the viewers. )

A last note ... Because the same-colored rectangular shapes have the very same location, they're "equidecomposable" (also known as "scissors conforming" ) : it's feasible to reduce one right into a limited variety of polygonal items that rebuild to make the various other. While there's at the very least one standard operating procedure for establishing just how to make it, the resulting items aren't always rather. Some preferred breakdown evidence of the Pythagorean Theorem-- such as Proof # 36 on Cut-the-Knot-- show a details, clear pattern for reducing up the number's 3 squares, a pattern that relates to great triangulars. I have yet to locate an in a similar way uncomplicated reducing pattern that would relate to all triangulars and also show that my same-colored rectangular shapes "clearly" have the very same location.

(An additional workout for the viewers, probably? : )

2019-05-07 21:11:12