What choices are there for cross reducing problems apart from aspect oriented shows?

Aspect oriented shows assures to manage cross reducing problems, yet I'm not entirely marketed on it yet. Have there been any kind of various other efforts to manage this trouble?

2019-05-04 08:30:59
Source Share
Answers: 4

In basic tagging code components with a declarative attribute, yet especially the Attribute system in the C#/. NET/Mono globe.

2019-12-05 00:23:37

I'm no specialist on AOP, yet from reviewing it for many years, it has actually constantly felt like a weak kind of the metaprogramming offered by Lisp, specifically components like its metaobject method.

This need to come as not a surprise, I intend : Gregor Kiczales was just one of the writers of AMOP, and also later on created AspectJ for Java!

2019-12-04 10:01:53

There are numerous means to take on the troubles of crosscutting problems :

  • Use Better Design Patterns, Idioms, or Abstraction Mechanisms : Code might be crosscutting despite the fact that it can be modularized. In order to keep the code, you will certainly require to refactor to make use of the layout strategy that can modularize it. Such refactoring might present crosscutting of a various kind, yet with any luck what crosscuts is secure, and also not most likely to transform.

  • Create Richer Language Features : Many indications of crosscutting can be addressed via far better abstraction devices, and also occasionally new language attributes are essential. As an example, advanced languages that include useful and also object - oriented attributes usually do not use as several layout patterns, due to the fact that they aren't essential. Keep in mind that layout patterns themselves can be crosscutting in nature , due to the fact that they define the duties of numerous various things and also courses. In Java, representation can usually be made use of as opposed to a facet, although at a greater runtime price. As an example, making use of representation, you can sustain the site visitor pattern over thousands of courses with simply a pair lines of code. The DJ library from Northeastern is one reflective remedy that does simply that. Mixins are an effective strategy readily available in C+npls (yet not Java) and also can offer you several of the very same usages instances as a facet.

  • Give Better Tool Support : Techniques such as making use of grep and also executing refactoring procedures can manage troubles connected to crosscutting code. As an example, the name of a method proclaimed in a user interface can cross the program. (Note the technological distinction below : It is the name of the method, not the method is execution, that crosscuts.) This generally isn't a trouble in an IDE like Eclipse, where you can make use of the "rename refactoring" to transform every one of the areas in your code that make use of the name. This way, it is feasible to not require language attributes when the shows setting is meaningful sufficient for you.

  • Usage Domain - Specific Languages : The very early facet languages, which came prior to AspectJ, were domain name - details and also related to just particular troubles, such as string synchronization or information - circulation evaluation for successfully incorporating function make-ups. These languages were speculative, yet appeared very effective at modularizing problems that or else were crosscutting.

  • Usage Generative Programming Techniques : Stepping up to the meta degree could be taken into consideration an execution strategy for facet - oriented shows, yet it is a large adequate location that it goes beyond straightforward facets. Generative strategies (where a program creates resource code for an additional program) are additionally connected to domain name - details languages.

For every one of these, I assume researching AOP is ideal. AOP can aid you expand your perceptions of code, also if you do not make use of an AOP language.

2019-12-04 09:38:28

When feasible, you can envelop cross-cutting problems right into different components that are after that made use of throughout the application using dependence shot. This permits you to rather decouple the cross-cutting problem execution from it's usage throughout the code.

This does not constantly function elegantly, though. That's the factor individuals are attempting to resolve the concern with points like AOP.

2019-05-07 23:45:01